We begin 2023 with the past year having ended on a high note. The results of the mid-term elections were an unequivocal sign that most Americans listened to Liz Cheney when she said Donald Trump should never be allowed to become president again.
They went even further and said they didn’t want any Trump wannabes in power either.
What a wonderful way to begin 2023. Our nation’s willingness to stand up against homegrown tyranny was put to the test and we passed it!
But the struggle for democracy is not over yet. Trump was a terrible president because he is a terrible man who affected us in terrible ways. It would be a serious mistake to believe we can simply put Trump behind us as if he was never President. We have to rethink our thinking about the role each of us plays in preserving the way of life we treasure.
For one thing, we would do well to admit that our own cynicism about American politics probably played a role in Trump gaining power.
It’s easy to call everybody a crook, to believe the government is controlled by “dark money, or to promote the idea that the government is the problem and the weaker it is, the better.
I confess that at times I have found myself thinking this way, but I now realize that whenever I have I was assuming our democracy would always be there. I was taking it for granted as if it were a rock never to be moved.
Trump proved how wrong that attitude was – and is. In the real world of today’s politics, American style democracy is always fragile, as our founders knew it would be. Cynicism is so dangerous because it produces apathy that leads us to abandon our role as citizens to keep our democracy strong. We can do better…and must.
A second thought is that we need to recover our trust in the reality of truth.
Trump began his presidency using phrases such as “fake media” and “alternative facts” and making evidence seem like a “he said/she said” proposition in order to undercut and undermine our trust that truth actually exists.
He and everyone around him, every Republican politician who supported him, and every American who voted for him, wanted the nation to reject the belief that truth is real and stable.
Not knowing the whole truth doesn’t mean truth doesn’t exist, but Trump et al. tried to convince the nation that searching for truth was a waste of time, that truth was and is whatever people believe it is.
If we hope to recover from the Trump years, it will involve a re-establishment of our trust in truth. It is a simple thing, really. We accept a conclusion to be true because it is based on the best evidence and facts available to us and do not vary from that truth until new evidence and facts emerge.
A third thought I want to suggest is that without trust in the reality of truth, moral standards are impossible to establish.
The reason Trump denied the reality of truth is because he was and is profoundly immoral, which is why he is the embodiment of evil. The word “evil” literally means “profoundly immoral.” That is Donald Trump.
Moral leadership is not possible when a nation doesn’t believe in truth. The United States lost the trust of other nations during the Trump presidency because they could not trust that we believed in being truthful about anything. They believed he would say and do anything to benefit himself at their expense, and they were right.
Moral leadership tells the truth and holds itself to account for its failures when it doesn’t. Frail and flawed human beings are still capable of exerting moral leadership, and the nation should and must expect it of our political leaders.
Fourth, we need to renew our allegiance to the Constitution.
That begins with reading it in order to see both its beauty and its genius and to gain a fresh appreciation for the core principles on which everything depends. That is especially true for the rule of law. Without it nothing works except raw power.
Being a nation of laws means that laws must be applied equally to everyone without regard to race, creed, color, station in life, position in life, or anything else.
Applying the law to everyone equally is under challenge as I write this in at least two ways.
The first is whether or not voters will hold the people they support to their primary duty, upholding their oath of office to preserve and protect the Constitution. To vote for or support anyone who is unwilling to do that is to vote against one’s own country. It represents a profound betrayal of being a citizen of this great nation.
The second is to expect Donald Trump to be brought to trial if the evidence says he committed the crimes of which he is accused. No exception can be tolerated. How such a step would affect the country is immaterial because nothing would do greater harm than allowing his being a former president to allow him to be above the rule of law.
His fate should be determined solely and only by the evidence, period. Otherwise, he will be allowed to undermine our democracy even though he is out of office.
A fifth thought about the role we play in preserving our way of life is to teach our children everything about American history, everything, the good and the bad alike.
Enough of book banning and uniformed incendiary claims that white children are being taught to hate America by religious extremists whose understanding of morality exalts self-righteous moralism.
Telling all our children the truth about the slaughter of native Americans, about slavery, segregation, anti-Semitism, or any failure of our nation to live up to its stated ideals does not diminish their patriotism, it humanizes it.
Indeed, the way to become a more perfect union is to be honest with ourselves about the many ways we have not been. Intentional ignorance protects nothing while knowledge gives us hope for making life better than it has been or is.
One final thought is that we can connect protecting and preserving our way of life and the moral conviction that for all of us to do well, all of us have to do well, not just some of us.
The reason social programs are necessary is because capitalism creates economic inequality. That’s not an opinion, it is a fact, and it is why the fear-mongering that goes on about “socialism” ought to offend all of us.
We don’t have a free market. We have a market largely controlled by corporations to maximize their profits. This is why millions don’t make a livable wage and why things like Obamacare are so necessary.
Before it was made law, former Speaker of House John Boehner said something to the effect that Obamacare was “the greatest threat to our freedom” in the history of the nation.
How utterly ridiculous for him to argue that a program that would help the 40 million Americans who could not afford health insurance and did not have access to healthcare represented a grave threat to democracy. Ten years later I wish Boehner and all those who agreed with him would explain just how Obamacare has threatened our democracy.
Indeed, in an economy that allows corporate America to have all the power, the only advocate ordinary Americans have that offsets corporate power is the government, a government that is supposed to be of the people, by the people, and for the people.
Rather than worrying about the poor getting help they don’t need, we will be a better and stronger nation if we focus on how to make sure no American family is left behind economically or educationally.
Helping people have a decent life never has and never will threaten our freedom. What does and always has is economic injustice that thrives on the haves getting more and more and have-nots less and less.
These, then, are some of the things on which I hope you will reflect as we begin 2023. If we allow them to shape our thinking and our attitudes and guide our actions, each of us will be doing our part to protect and preserve the Constitution and the way of life it makes possible.
To do that will mean this year will be even better than the way 2022 ended.
Another gem written by Lin post
Thank you. Happy New Year!
Jan,
I like your clear optimism while facing the realities pressing on our nation. I, too, have been guilty of cynicism and complacency about our politics. We need to guard against both while avoiding polyannaism. No longer can we afford to take Democracy for granted; it needs our nourishment, constantly.
Thanks for this optimistic, realistic statement as we go into the coming year.
Happy New Year to you and your family.’
Gene
Happy New year, Gene, and as always thank you for your comment.
Jan, there is a lot of meat in this post! And your points of view are expressed with enthusiasm that “we the people” can truly feel good about today. And you rightly suggest that “the struggle for democracy is not over yet”. “We” must not settle back, into even temporary complacency, as we watch the chaos that is sure to continue in our future at the hands of Maga traitors and the unrecognizable Republican party.
1. I too admit to allowing “cynicism” create the opening that Trump took advantage off, by driving a dump truck full of garbage into our American lives. But, here is where I have the most hope. We did prevail in the recent elections! And we showed that our own cynicism could be overcome by “taking appropriate action”. Also, Trump has seen his best days. His demise began with the recent election, continued with the indisputable “proof” provided to us by the Select Committee on January 6, his power is being diminished daily by Republican chaos, and our current Justice Department is ready and prepared to defend “the rule of law”, indict him, and hold him accountable. This is an amazingly optimistic turn around of events.
2. With respect to “we need to recover our trust in the reality of truth”, this is where I have much worry and concern. Trump and the complicit Repbublicans, in my mind, have won this battle. They have not won the war. But “we the people” have to re-think our immediate strategies and actions to overcome this tragic attack on truth. And the war will take place in cultural fronts, social fronts, business fronts, political fronts, and spiritual fronts for us to get back to any kind of “truthful and moral” normalcy. This attack on truth will remain as the single most important factor that will continue “The Great Divide” in America! “WE” have a lot of work to do in this war on truth. And it will not be won soon.
3. Your most powerful and important conclusion is “that without trust in the reality of truth, moral standards are impossible to establish”. Whoa! What I feel you are saying, is that we have reached the point where because of this great divide on truth, we can not begin to tackle the task of re-establishing morals standards that we can some how agree on and “legislate” into action. I am actually “depressed” significantly by this catastrophic dilemma. My observation is that a significant portion of the American population lives their lives having established “immoral standards” that are entrenched in their ways of life. Our biggest challenge as a society, is to figure out how we can turn this around. It appears to me now, that humanity’s historical struggle of “good vs. evil”, which reached our doorstep long ago, has now taken a giant step forward toward our possible demise.
4. Yes, “we need to renew our allegiance to the Constitution”. Easier said than done! Many, if not most, Americans today still have very little knowledge of what Our Constitution actually contains. I vividly remember the day that Wally brought in a gift to all of us in Town Square at my community of Las Palmas. It was a beautifully dispayed little booklet entitled “The Declaration of Independence and The Constituion of the United States of America”. His instruction to each of us was to read both documents thoroughly. We then spent the next few weeks discussing and learning about our historical past, and what that past means to Our Future. The Great Divide in America is fueled by one half of our constuency that has been brainwashed to believe that their side is on the “right” side of the Constitution. This is the second “Big Lie” that we must overturn. And then, it might take another “Constitutional Convention” to protect our future.
5. And again yes, we must “teach our children everything about American history, everything, the good and the bad alike”. We will not prevail in all of this, uness we return a primary focus of American life on “Education”. Our education system today is “in shambles” with respect to teaching all how to function and to preserve “The Common Good”. We must legislate that all citizens of our still good country attend mandatory Civics classes, just as they are required to do for math, science, literature, and language.
Yes Jan, we still have a lot of work to do my friend.
John
John, been traveling the last few days. Thank you for your comments on the points I made. The issue of truth is probably the cornerstone for everything else we can do to change the current circumstances, but, as you say, truly difficult to achieve. The story about what Wally did is one to remember. A friend here who is 92 keeps saying that the one thing he believes the country needs is a nationwide study of the Constitution. Wally was ahead of the times. Who knew the study you all did would be a model for the nation at this critical time.? As always, thank you for your thoughts.
Wonderful as always, Linn. One quick thought—what if our elected officials at local, state and federal levels, as a requirement of being sworn in, were obligated to pass the same citizenship test we ask of those who want to make their home here official? It seems that some of the more raucous of the newbie legislators’ number don’t have a clue as to the tradition, import, or structure of the work of government. I took the test as an experiment a couple of months ago and it’s not a walk in the park. 🙂 Here’s a link: https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/document/questions-and-answers/100q.pdf
Perry, what an excellent suggestion. I plan to take the test myself. I hope others will use the link to do the same. Thank you.