April 12, 1861 is a historic moment for the nation, but a day of shame for many native-born southerners like me.
It was the day Confederate soldiers fired on the United States military housed at Fort Sumpter in South Carolina’s Charleston Harbor and started the Civil War.
That war was a tragic effort to destroy the “united” part of the United States, driven by a determination to defend the morally reprehensible practice of slavery.
In the end my ancestors firing on Fort Sumpter cost the lives of 600,000 soldiers on both sides and the death of thousands of women and children and the elderly, mostly in the South where the majority of the war was fought.
Here’s the question I wish I could ask my relatives: “How could you have possibly believed that what you were doing was the right thing to do?”
But I think I know the answer to my own question. They were consumed by white supremacy to such a degree that it eroded their moral conscience.
At that point they were so eaten up by their sense of grievance against the federal government for setting all black slaves free that they were willing to fight a war that divided the country and would destroy it.
Not even losing the war resurrected their moral conscience as they began to replace slavery with a system of racial segregation that dehumanized black Americans as much as owning them did.
It took another 100 years to end legal segregation, but racial prejudice born of a belief in white supremacy still infects millions of Americans.
The MAGA movement Donald Trump established is the most visible example of it at the moment, in large measure because of evangelical Christians.
No MAGA Republican or evangelical will admit such a thing, but now we have data to prove it is true.
A recent survey conducted jointly by Public Religion Research Institute (PPRI) and E Pluribus Unum measured Americans’ views on race and structural racism.
The survey asked 11 questions on a wide range of topics – attitudes about white supremacy and racial inequality, the impact of discrimination on African American economic mobility, the treatment of African Americans in the criminal justice system, general perceptions of race, and whether racism is still a significant problem today.
The answers given to the 11 questions were then correlated into what the survey administrators called a “Structural Racism Index” scale.
Here are some of the noteworthy results that index showed:
– By race and ethnicity, white Americans are the most likely to score high on the structural racism index (indicating greater attitudes of racism).
– White Republicans scored higher than white independents or Democrats.
– Predominantly white religious groups score highest on the structural racism scale with white evangelical Protestants scoring the highest.
– Nine out of ten Republicans support maintaining Confederate monuments around the country while less than a third of Democrats do.
– Among religious groups, white evangelical Protestants are the most likely to support preserving the history of the Confederacy with memorials and statues (76%).
– Less than half of all Americans know that there laws segregating public schools in America ever existed. (https://www.prri.org/research/creating-more-inclusive-public-spaces-structural-racism-confederate-memorials-and-building-for-the-future/)
MAGA Republicans and evangelical leaders will not believe the truth this survey tells them about themselves, and the reason they won’t is the same as the one that explains why southerners in 1861 didn’t see themselves for what they were – their moral conscience had been eroded by their racial attitudes.
Thus, a century and a half after the Civil War, and some sixty years after major civil rights legislation was passed by the U. S. Congress and signed into law, we are still fighting among ourselves over the same issues that produced the Civil War – race and white supremacy.
Most troubling about our history of racism and its present day manifestations is that once people give in to their prejudices, only a few ever change their minds. Some even become radicalized.
For MAGA Republicans and evangelicals Donald Trump was the catalyst for their radicalization. We all know by now that his influence has been cult-like. He tried to tell us he knew how to exploit racism, manipulate political grievances, and politicize evangelical moralism into blind loyalty when he said he could shoot someone in the middle of Fifth Avenue in New York and not lose a vote, but most of us dismissed what it as talk.
Not surprisingly, then, we find ourselves still fighting against the kind of white supremacy and all the evil it produces that was the cause of the Civil War a century and a half ago.
What is different between then and now is that the war is not between armies, but between radicalized Republican politicians and their opponents in our federal and state legislatures, in city councils, school boards, and even in religious communities.
The flash point in the war we are now fighting has moved from the battlefield to the ballot box.
What should hearten us is that the future of America does not depend on trying to do the impossible, which is to get MAGA Republicans to see that what they are doing is wrong.
It only depends on defeating them, and that is something within our grasp.
had the leaders of the South been labeled as traitors and treated as such, i doubt we would have the much of the idiocy we see among the ‘wanna be rebels’, that we are seeing.
Guy, that’s what you call “hard truth.”
Excellent article. Can I post on Facebook, IF I get the nerve? Too many friends and relatives for the mold…
Please post it, Willie. Let the chips fall where they may.
Jan,
We southerners need a regular reminder of what our misguided ancestors did to our nation by beginning a civil war in April 1861. Thank you for using your blog to accomplish this!! Sadly, the racism abides in America.
Bill Blackwell
Bill, it was certainly not what we were taught in school in Lynchburg. At least, I wasn’t. I was told never even use the name, “Civil War.” Instead, it was “the war between the states.” It’s amazing that kind of thinking (or lack thereof) is still around.
Written by white suburban leftists with zero exposure or interaction in diverse southern cities. This is incredibly inacurate, dishonest leftist garbage. Have you lived in Houston, New Orleans or any of the like southern cities? Of course not. Why do you continue to push division from a computer in a white suburb? This is a leftist virtue signal trash. I live and interact in all day every day in our southern cities. Stop puhsing the “whiyte supremacy” crap to pander for support of your extremist views.
I continue to “push” what you call “white supremacy crap” because of people like you.
Jan
It does feel like a subtle yet powerful war. Last week in Maine, a man wearing a tee “ God is great God is good Liberals are crazy” came face to face with me wearing a Bernie Sanders shirt. We both smiled at each other. Reducing fear of the other may be our best hope
If that doesn’t work, let’s crush them at the ballot box
Dixcy, Reducing fear would surely help, but I think MAGA Republicans are angry as much as fearful and that is difficult mixture to overcome. I’m afraid at this point crushing them at the ballot box is the only way we can reach them. If they win, they will be even more radicalized.
Re Mr. Tuttle’s comment, actually, I’m both a big-city and small-town product. I lived in Manhattan for twenty years, in Washington Heights, which was 95% non-white. Living in a building with 54 families from many races and religions, from many parts of the world, made it rather impossible to be closed-minded. The lobby at holidays was a thing of beauty—we had a big building party each year and shared food and decorations celebrating Christmas, Hanukah, Ramadan, Kwanzaa and the Solstice. Conversely, it’s in small cities, towns and suburbs—where people live only among those like them—where racism festers. That’s because folks only know their own kind. It’s hard to maintain stereotypes once you come to know those from other backgrounds as neighbors and friends.
Thank you for your comment, Perry. You highlight the critical role geographical and social context plays in the shaping of attitudes. I hope everyone who reads this blog also reads what you wrote.
Jan,
Excellent analysis, again. The key to the saving of our Democracy lies squarely in your last to paragraphs.
As you ca see, Gene, I continue to hope, sometimes “in spite of” what I see rather than “because of.” Thanks.