A friend sent me the link to a New York times column by Charles Blow in which he said: “Folks, Kavanaugh is only one soldier, albeit an important one, in a larger battle…Stop thinking you’re in a skirmish when you’re at war.”
Exactly.
If you don’t believe the Kavanaugh hearings were part of a larger struggle – “war,” if you will, against our federal system of checks and balances, you are not paying attention.
Don’t take my word for it. Here is a link to an article by historian Christopher Browning (about which another friend alerted me – I have good friends). (https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2018/10/25/suffocation-of-democracy/).
It is the most informative and alarming article I have read to date that puts what is happening in our country in its proper historical context. Here is an example:
“In the 1920s, the US pursued isolationism in foreign policy and rejected participation in international organizations like the League of Nations. America First was America alone…At the same time, high tariffs crippled international trade… The country witnessed an increase in income disparity and a concentration of wealth at the top, and both Congress and the courts eschewed regulations to protect against the self-inflicted calamities of free enterprise run amok. The government also adopted a highly restrictionist immigration policy aimed at preserving the hegemony of white Anglo-Saxon Protestants against an influx of Catholic and Jewish immigrants. (Various measures barring Asian immigration had already been implemented between 1882 and 1917.) These policies left the country unable to respond constructively to either the Great Depression or the refugee crisis of the 1930s.”
Change the date from the 1920s to 2018 and his words still describe the America we are living in.
But it is worse than that.
“If the US has someone whom historians will look back on as the gravedigger of American democracy,” Browning says, “it is Mitch McConnell. He stoked the hyperpolarization of American politics to make the Obama presidency as dysfunctional and paralyzed as he possibly could. As with parliamentary gridlock in Weimar [Germany], congressional gridlock in the US has diminished respect for democratic norms, allowing McConnell to trample them even more. Nowhere is this vicious circle clearer than in the obliteration of traditional precedents concerning judicial appointments…Whatever secret reservations McConnell and other traditional Republican leaders have about Trump’s character, governing style, and possible criminality, they openly rejoice in the payoff they have received from their alliance with him and his base.”
These are only snippets of this brilliant article that will shake you to your core, but a must read nonetheless since avoiding the truth is never a good option, especially in a crisis.
The hard reality is that our nation is divided precisely because we are at war over what kind of country we want to have and the future we are creating right now.
Trump Republicans want an America I don’t want to live in.
Their values are not my values. Their attitude toward immigrants, racial minorities, and GLBTQ Americans is not my attitude. Their beliefs they call Christian are not my beliefs.
When you think about it, we actually are in a fight that feels like a war, primarily because everything I believe in seems to be under assault.
What is more, having finished Woodward’s book, Fear, the most obvious and honest conclusion to reach is that Trump is totally incompetent as President, mainly because he has no interest in being informed about anything, nothing, not even the smallest issue.
The man just doesn’t care whether what anyone else says because he believes he is right about everything. His senior staff spend all their time trying to keep him from plunging the world in war, undoing critical alliances, or undermining our economy with tariffs nations discovered in the 19th c. were a bad deal for everyone.
Without a doubt Kavanaugh was a skirmish in a very real war Trump is waging against competence, science, and values.
Christopher Browning describes what Trump is doing as “the gradual suffocation of democracy.”
Nothing says it better than that, which means that the only thing that can save us is for those of us who see what is happening to take up the mantle of responsible citizenship.
November is the first step and it is a HUGE one. To say this is the most important election in our nation’s history is an understatement.
Winning control of the House will stop Trump in his tracks. Even if Republicans retain control of the Senate (and they may not), they will not be able to pass a single piece of legislation without support from House Democrats.
If you have any doubt about how critical that will be, listen to an unlikely voice in support of Democrats winning the House and even the Senate.
Max Boot is conservative scholar, writer, and pre-Trump Republican who serves as the Jeanne J. Kirkpatrick Senior Fellow in National Security Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations.
He says Trump is the most dishonest and unprincipled President in our nation’s history, and a danger to everything we hold sacred as a democracy.
He further says that every American who is paying attention to facts rather than Fix News and company must vote a straight Democratic ticket in November.
Let me say again. Boot is a highly respected conservative and former Republican, and he is saying the key to saving our country is for all Americans to vote Democratic in the mid-terms.
And here’s the thing. I believe that is exactly what we are going to do.
In spite of Trump being President, I still believe in the common sense wisdom of the majority of Americans, and I believe that majority will vote to stop the gradual suffocation of our democracy taking place at the hands of Donald Trump on November 6.
I’m glad you’ve shared Browning’s insightful article with your blog subscribers. I was stunned when I read it, primarily because it has confirmed my own fears as a lowly BA history major somewhat obsessed with the inter-war history of Germany. Later in life I was privileged to know several older German immigrant friends, now deceased, who lived that history. Their tales were almost unbelievable, or perhaps stories I didn’t want to believe. Unfortunately we seem to be living a parallel history that the GOP is blind to.
Bob, it’s the Republicans who confused me the most. They live in the same country we do, and their children and grandchildren will share the same future ours will. What are they telling them now to justify their disregard for basic values, common decency, and a commitment to telling the truth? Thanks for the reference for the article.
Jan, for the life of me I can’t understand why there aren’t a few republicans in the senate who don’t use their power to change the direction we are headed. Surely there are good, smart republicans who see this crap. Even the handful of “moderates” who we count on to bring sanity to the party nearly always fall in line with Trump when the chips are down. I judt don’t get it. What are we missing?
Wilbur, I think what we are seeing is the result of the radicalization of the Republican Party that began with Newt Gringrich in 1990s. The have purged most moderates and will soon have none. It will never again be the GOP it once was.
Jan,
You have deftly melded Blow’s (figurative) “call to war” with Browning’s scholarly and scary comparison, along with your own declaration that “Trump Republicans want an America I don’t want to live in.” I share your view that their values and Christian(sic) beliefs are not mine!
Not being familiar with him, I am glad you introduced me to Max Bolt. That a man who is a highly respected conservative and former Republican would say that the key to saving our country is for all Americans to vote for Democrats in the mid-terms is astounding! And refreshing.
Thank you, my friend, for yet again standing tall for what is right!
Bill Blackwell
Thank you for your reply, Bill. The Browning article ought to be required reading for all Americans before the mid-terms. Re Max Boot, I am becoming convinced that the most potent anti-Trump voices right now are former Republicans like him who are genuine conservatives while maintaining a commitment to facts and the rightful place of government, and feel like Trump has hijacked their party with the help of sycophant Republicans in Congress.
I fully agree with your last sentence. Just hope there are enough of them?!
The great German playwright Bertold Brecht warns us in the following poem, that should democracy fall, those solely to blame will be the people themselves:
“Article One Of The Weimar Constitution”
From the People proceeds the power of the State.
– But where does it proceed to?
Yes, where is it proceeding to?
There’s some place it’s proceeding to.
The policeman proceeds through the station gate.
– But where does he proceed to?
There’s some place he’s proceeding to…
Look, there’s the whole lot on the march.
– But where are they marching to?
Yes, where are they marching to?
There’s some place that they’re marching to.
They wheel through the gate and under the arch.
– But where are they wheeling to?
There’s some place that they’re wheeling to…
The power of the State turns right about.
Something is in the air.
– What can be in the air?
There’s something in the air.
The power of the State gives a piercing shout
And yells: Get moving there!
– But moving why and where?
It yells: Get moving there!
There’s something standing in a crowd
Something which queries that.
Why should it query that?
What cheek to query that!
The state just shoots (for that’s allowed)
And something falls down flat.
What was it fell down flat?
What made it fall like that?
The power of the State sees something spill.
There’s something in the (dirt).
What’s lying in the (dirt)?
Something’s lying in the (dirt).
There’s something lying deadly still
– The People, why, that’s it!
Can that really be it?
Yes, that is really it.
Nigel, I think Bill said it best. Thanks, again.
Nigel,
The poets usually “get it.” Thanks for sharing that wisdom with Jan’s readers!
Bill Blackwell