The racist comments of L. A. Clippers owner, Donald Sterling, and now his lifetime ban from any affiliation with the NBA, have captured America’s attention, including President Obama’s.
The ban is a decisive statement about the consequences of overt racism in today’s America.
But we should not think for one minute it means we live in a “post-racism” America.
“Post-racism,” a term even President Obama likes to use, is another name for “colorblindness.”
“Colorblindness” has been the basis for several successful court challenges to Affirmative Action such as the recent Supreme Court ruling upholding a voter-approved law in Michigan banning the use of racial preferences in higher education admissions.
Treat everybody equally, colorblindness or post-racism says. The playing field is now level. No preferential treatment for anyone. Equal opportunity rules.
It sounds reasonable, a path to a non-racist America, except for two major hiccups.
One is that the playing field being level doesn’t solve the problem. Let me use an analogy.
Let’s say you sponsor a mile race for kids that is open to everyone regardless of color…except the white kids have already run three laps. So they win even though everyone has an equal chance to be in the race.
That is the problem Affirmative Action tries to remedy. It’s called present advantages/disadvantages because of past discrimination. Colorblindness pretends like no such advantages and disadvantages still exist, but they do and we know they do.
The other hiccup re this post-racism era we are supposed to be living in is the fact that we all know that condemnation of public racism doesn’t eliminate private racism still at work in our society.
Cliven Bundy, the Nevada racist rancher who was in the news until Sterling pushed him aside, is a perfect example. His racism runs so deep he doesn’t even see it in himself. And he is not alone.
Which brings me to my primary reason for writing. I want to recommend a book by Ian Haney Lopez, Professor of Law at the University of California, Berkeley. The title tells it all: Dog Whistle Politics: How Coded Racial Appeals Have Reinvented Racism and Wrecked the Middle Class.
This is the most important book about the moral problem of racism and its continuing effects on our collective life I have ever read. It should be read by every American. In future Blogs I will discuss some of what he says.
For now it is enough to say that anyone who reads his book will see how utterly naive it is to believe colorblindness is a path to racial justice or that we now live in a post-racism America, Donald Sterling suffering the consequences of his public racist remarks notwithstanding.
Have a copy of Lopez’ book here next to me. Thank you for the recommendation!
John Rodenberg, CFRE
Vice President of Philanthropy
CCH | 303 Hegenberger Road, Suite 201, Oakland, CA 94621
Office (510) 746-4227
Mobile (817) 944-1647
jrodenberg@cchnc.net http://www.cchnc.org
This has been painfully obvious to me for a long time; that how racism exists might have changed but that it still exists is everywhere, especially if you know someone well who will offer glimpses of their life and you see it in their faces or hear it in their voices. Woe are we! Affirmative Action must be maintained!
I am about 2/3 of the way through Dog Whistle Politics. For me, it is an interesting, but very depressing, read. I think there is no doubt that racism exists in America, and in fact is quite common. What depresses me is learning how wide spread the use of Dog Whistle tactics is among our politicians. I think we have a right to expect much better than that from them. But frankly, I don’t expect it. I have reached a point of severe dissatisfaction with the vast majority of our “leaders” and our current political process in general. When I hear Franklin Graham say publicly that we don’t need better background checks for gun sales because “God has already run background checks on all of us” it drives me up a wall, to say the least.
PS: I am not a fan of Affirmative Action, I think it is simply another form of racism.
Wally,
Affirmative Action has been the primary way to overcome the disadvantages minorities have endured because of slavery, segregation, and continuing racism. “Colorblindness” pretends all those disadvantages have been overcome. Lopez documents in the book why this is not true.