“The way we define success isn’t working” was the way Arianna Huffington put it in a speech she made a few weeks ago at a conference she called together with Mika Brzezinski, co-host of MSNBC’s Morning Joe. She went on to say, “More, bigger, better — we can’t do that anymore.”
If I didn’t know better I would have thought she was speaking at a religious gathering. What she said goes to the core of the practical application of the message of most world religions. It seems there is a small, nascent movement afoot among women to redefine success that stands over against the typical definition most of us bought into when we were young. Whether they acknowledge it or not, or even know it, this “movement” echoes the words of Jesus who said that life does not consist in the abundance of possessions (Luke 12:15). Of course, in many respects you would never know Jesus said such a thing by the way Christians have sought success in the same way everybody else has. And so have most churches, as if deep down they believe more and bigger are “better.”
But now the consequences of our materialistic view of success are becoming apparent. People feel pushed and pulled, stressed and strewn, all the while running head long over a cliff in the mad pursuit of the American notion of success. The toll on families and individuals is becoming unmanageable, and, for some, unbearable. It is encouraging to learn that some people – even though they themselves are examples of the success they are questioning – are saying enough is enough, that there has to be a different and better way to live.
Yet the vast majority of people are just trying to get by, to make ends meet, to put food on the table and clothes on their children. The more I read about the consequences of the current insanity known as “the Sequester,” the more I realize what a privileged life I am living. With adequate housing, food for three meals a day, money to buy clothes or replace a worn out car, freedom to think about where we might go for our next vacation, I don’t feel much of the impact government cutbacks and a bad economy are causing. If truth be told, millions of Americans and most of the world’s population would love to have the life I do. Put simply, I live a privileged life.
I don’t say this to make myself or anyone else in my situation feel guilty. I have worked hard all my life, and still do. To enjoy the fruits of my own labor is not a bad thing. But I don’t ever want to become so comfortable that I forget or ignore the struggles others are having. I am grateful for the life I have. In fact, I want always to be grateful because gratitude serves us better than guilt. It produces better lives. Indeed, I think one of the reasons I think a lot about people being hurt by government policies and economic downturns is because I know I didn’t get here solely on my own. I had a lot of help from others.
All of us need and get help from others, directly or indirectly. I want to be one of the “others” for someone else. That is why I think any effort to redefine success is a healthy thing. Yes, it is privileged people like Arianna Huffington and Mika Brzezinski – and me – who have the time and money and power and convenience to think about such things, but in the long run a widespread recognition that life is about spirit, about relationships, about giving and not just getting, will benefit everyone, enrich most and not just some.
There is work to be done, then. Changing perceptions of success will be slow, of course, but it has to begin somewhere and sometime. So I’m stepping into a stream of new consciousness that is already flowing, led by women who are speaking ancient truth in fresh ways, and in doing so may save our culture from ultimate meaninglessness.
Thanks, Jan. I wish it hadn’t taken me 60+ years to figure out the important things in life, but glad I “get” it now.
Right in line with the video in yesterday’s study hour & sermon at SOJ.
We saw and shared thoughts on Brueggemann’s presentation at the Gen. Assembly….What does it mean GIVE US THIS DAY OUR DAILY BREAD?
Thanks for this…….
I am sensing that ‘consciously’ bringing forward a new thought process that is ‘ancient’ in all their diversity, can bring forth new possibilities. I am grateful!
On a recent trip, my wife and I heard about a bad home fire that destroyed everything, and we began to think about hat it would be like if our home burned while we were way, or if someone broke in and took all of our “stuff”. We came to the awareness that everything we truly valued was right there in the car with us. Thanks for your insights. I hope a new definition of success will catch on. It may very well save us!
The values of which you speak require a maturity that is a long time in coming for most and never happens for many. We would be much better served to seek “significance” over success any day. That objective has a transcendent quality. It is requisite maturity, especially spiritual maturity, which caused Jesus to often say, “To those who have eyes to see… or ears to hear.”
You mean the bible doesn’t say “Thee with the most toys wins.”? I’m confused… 😉
At least not in the women’s version. Glad to have you as a reader, Luke.
Well spoken! I certainly agree with your choice of the word “insanity” to describe our Sequester. As I recall, it was a known dumb idea to hold us for a bit while we figured out a better way. Well, Sequester is still with us. Somehow we skipped the step of figuring out a better way. The harm being done to things like Head Start & Meals on Wheels is simply inexcusable, in my view.
I share your view of living a privileged life, I think I also do so. A difference is that though I think I worked hard during my career, I don’t think I do now. So for me life is good, but I am mindful of those for whom that is not the case. I guess I would say that I am now in the distribution, rather than accumulation, phase of my life. More “stuff'” doesn’t please as much as being able to help someone else when and where I can.